Methodology

How the score works

This project uses a category-based score to track democratic erosion and authoritarian risk. The goal is not to create a sensational feed, but a disciplined early-warning instrument.

Core scoring logic

Scale

Each category is scored from 0 to 10, where higher values indicate greater democratic risk. The overall index is a weighted composite rather than a simple average.

Evidence hierarchy

Strong: final court rulings, statutes, executive orders, federal dockets, official data. Medium: reputable multi-outlet reporting or active litigation without final rulings. Weak: social media, unverified claims, or summaries without primary support.

Why curation matters

Curated trackers such as Trump Action Tracker are useful as discovery layers, but they should not move the score by themselves without stronger underlying evidence.

Category framework

CategoryWeight
Rule of Law & Court Compliance15%
Habeas Corpus & Due Process15%
Coercive State Power & Policing Norms15%
Political Targeting / Weaponization of Justice15%
Election Integrity & Peaceful Transfer15%
Press Freedom & Information Control10%
Civil Society & Associational Freedom5%
Institutional Checks & Anti-Corruption5%
Military & Intelligence Neutrality5%

What a redline means

Redlines are not just bad headlines

A redline is a threshold event that materially changes the level of democratic danger if credibly met. The score measures accumulation over time. A redline marks a more abrupt constitutional shock.

Why they matter so much

Some developments do not merely add risk. They change the kind of system you are living in. Open court defiance, politically motivated jailing, criminalized reporting, or override of certified election results can rapidly collapse the practical value of ordinary democratic safeguards.

How the tracker uses them

Each redline is labeled Not Triggered, Watch, or Triggered. “Watch” means there is meaningful evidence of movement toward the threshold. “Triggered” means the site judges that the threshold has been credibly crossed based on the strongest available evidence, even if broader legal or political debates continue afterward. A triggered redline does not automatically produce a 9.0+ score, but multiple simultaneous redline moves can justify a fast score increase even before full systemic breakdown occurs.

Visual system

Official meter

The official meter is now the single signature visual. It should appear on the homepage, social graphics, country landing pages, and report covers so people can identify the score at a glance.

Locked template rules

The locked template keeps the center score large, adds 0–10 reference numbers, marks the redline boundary at 9.0, and preserves a country tag plus provenance watermark.

Country template

To scale internationally, the same structure can swap in a country badge, country name, month, and updated score without losing recognition.